Help Me Decide! Acrylic Counter Stools

I've been dying to buy new counter stools for my island. 

I bought inexpensive ones when we first moved in because my girls were toddlers at the time, but they are getting older and now I'm ready for an update. 

While I still need something easy to clean, I want something a little more sophisticated. 

So, I think I want acrylic counter stools. Visually pleasing to the eye, I can wipe them down after kid messes and they are very design friendly.

Here is a pic of my kitchen island with the current counter stools.

Now, here's what I think would look fantastic!

These.... 

OR

These..

What do you think? Help me out here..Yes??? No??

XOXO

Jennifer